Skip to main content

Time to Repeal Kentucky's AMT

Republican gubernatorial candidate, Billy Harper, is already following through on what he's promising to do if elected Governor of Kentucky! He is leading a petition drive to repeal Kentucky's Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT). You'll see this tax referred to as the AMT (Alternative Minimum Tax) even though, technically, Kentucky's state version of the federal AMT is called the Alternative Minimum Calculation (or AMC). The AMC is a tax that is harmful to the prosperity of all Kentuckians as it penalizes businesses that struggle to succeed here.

If you favor a repeal of this onerous tax, sign the petition online. Why not have your voice heard? After all, Mr. Harper is certainly making it very easy for you to voice your opinion on a tax that hurts Kentucky. Billy Harper will be delivering this petition to the politicians in Frankfort. Yours truly has already added her name to the list!

Evidently, Billy Harper isn't just campaigning, he's already started the ball rolling on his first campaign promise! Nice work, Mr. Harper!!

Comments

Anonymous said…
Last summer's Special Session of the Kentucky General Assembly called by Gov. Fletcher did away with the AMC for businesses that gross under $3 million. The vote was 100-0 in the House and 38-0 in the State Senate.

Rep. Bill Farmer and 15 other Republican members of the House GOP Caucus have a Bill filed (HB 88) that would do away with the AMC completely. HB 87 by Rep. David Floyd and six other Republican House member does much the same. HB 119 sponsored by Democrat Rep. Mike Denham and co-sponsored by Republican Rep. C. B. Embry, Jr. also would repeal the AMC. All three Bills were introduced in the House of Representatives on January 2, 2007.

The question is will the Leadership in the House and Senate allow one of these Bills to be heard and voted on, and will the Fletcher Administration support such a Bill?

The governor, no matter who he or she is, can not do away with the AMC alone. A Bill doing so has to first pass in the House and Senate. If that happens, then the governor can sign it into law, or veto it.

State Representatives and State Senators can file as many Bills as they wish. However they have no control which Bills get consideration. The Leadership Teams and the Committee Chairmen pick the Bills to be considered, for there is not nearly enough time to deal with all of them.

Around 40 to 50% of Bills filed are given some type of consideration (hearings, discussion, debate and maybe votes), the rest die with no action being taken. Around 12 to 15% of Bills filed pass, and become law. The 2007 Session of the General Assembly has 26 more working days left. Nearly 300 Bills were filed in the first four days of this year's Session. Hundreds of more will be filed starting next week.

The AMC should be completely repealed.
Anonymous said…
And you are saying it wont be??
Rena Bernard said…
What I find curious is that Governor Fletcher ever signed it into law.
Anonymous said…
Dawn thats a great point... Why would he sign it into law??
Anonymous said…
Your points are good ones. The AMC should be repeaded completely. Gov. Fletcher's tax plan was reported to be neutral. There were many tax cuts (one of which took the Commonwealth's 500,000 lowest income citizens off the state income tax roles, we had for over 30 years been the state that taxed its poor at the highest rates in the nation) and those cuts to be off-set by the AMC.
As I type this I do not think the AMC will be repealed this Session. Things can change in Frankfort quickly, therefore I hope I am wrong. How that source of income (AMC for businesses grossing over $3 million a year) would be replaced without adding back in the earlier tax cuts, is also a question.
Anonymous said…
Dawn, If the AMC is applied correctly the THEORY behind the tax is actually kind of appealing.

However, as with a lot of things (laws) that look "good on paper" once the flaws are detected in practice - that law should be taken off of the table ... this is one of those ... so is KERA.

So far, the dems running, all 100 of them, have yet to talk "reality" and have yet to discuss real issues. All I have heard so far are outlines of "hypothesis'" -- I'm so tired of political hypothesis - I think some call that political rhetoric?

If Harper does this AMC change & if Harper can talk about how he WILL do away with KERA - I will switch my party and vote for Harper in the Primary.
Anonymous said…
The theory behind the AMC is interesting? It's a tax increase...
Rena Bernard said…
Yeah, RL, is a state tax increase on top of a FEDERAL tax increase. That's a death blow to struggling start up businesses! Why would they do business here in Kentucky when we add that burden on top of the federal burden they have to carry? I think Ky is only one of two or three states who impose such a tax. It's ridiculous!
Rena Bernard said…
Lady, what a lovely idea! Come on over -- we'd love to have another smart woman in the Conservative ranks! ;o) Unfortunately, it's too late to switch your party affiliation to vote in the primary. :o(

I don't really know that Billy Harper would be up for undoing KERA. That's a question I need to ask him soon. He did good work but was working within a political and status quo structure. Change comes more slowly that way...
Rena Bernard said…
Anon 10:45am, thanks for the update on what's happening in Frankfort on the AMC issue. That's all very good news -- let's hope those bills make it through!

When I talked with Mr. Harper yesterday, I mentioned these bills to him. I asked him if he thought maybe his early campaign ads and positions may have sparked them. I was surprised at what he said: "I sure hope so. That would be great. It doesn't matter to me who gets the credit for getting it done as long as we get it done."

Not your typical politician-style answer, is it?!
Anonymous said…
The Bills have been in the works since the Special Session last summer. A number of us in the GOP House Caucus and a few Democrats felt the AMC should have been completely. We could not get it done in the Special Session, but we did have 100% agreement in both parties and both the House and Senate, and with the Admministration to end it for businesses that gross under $3 million a year. We took what we could get done and started work on Bills to end the AMC on budinesses that goross over $3 milion to be filed in the 2007 Session. Three were filed the first day of the Session, January 2nd.
Anonymous said…
Dawn, you are right, not the typical politician answer and a great answer... Contrast that with Anne Northup saying “I really did not think I’d be in another political race so soon.” Shouldnt someone running for this high office, so important to the state be darn sure why they are running?
Rena Bernard said…
Mercedes, it sure seemed to me like Northup would have taken a season off and waited for Bunning to retire before running another campaign for any office. I truly thought that the Senate would have been her next goal rather than the Governor's mansion.

And yes, she should be very certain as to why she wants the office because people see right through the rhetoric these days.
Anonymous said…
As one of the 16 Republicans legislators that have co-sponsored HB 88 which would repeal the AMC, we today received the fiscal note statement from the Legislative Research Commission regarding the cost of the Bill.

Their study shows the Commonwealth would lose $60.9 million in revenue in 2007-2008 with the repeal of this unfair tax.

Reportedly this will result in Rep. Harry Moberly, Jr., D-Richmond, Chairman of the House Appropriations & Revenue Committee, and the House Democrat Leadership Team not allowing this Bill or the other two Bills that repeal the AMC from being discussed or considered.

Their concern is putting in place some other souces of revenue (tax) to replace the AMC or what programs to cut back (education, social services, public protection, etc.). They clearly do not want to do either one at this time.

While several of us will continue to push to repeal the AMC, it appears the chances to do that this Session are slim to none.
Rena Bernard said…
Anon 11:37am, thanks for your public service. I'm certainly glad you're in Frankfort!

The thing I find most surprising about other legislators trying to find a replacement for an unfair tax is just that -- it's unfair; it should never have been counted as revenue for the state to begin with. So, trying to "make up" for the shortfall as a result of doing what's right is kind of ridiculous in my book.

How about this? Encourage business growth in this state by cutting out the pork; removing unfair tax burdens from entrepreneurs; and building a Commonwealth that is robust enough to keep her natives here rather than sending them elsewhere to build careers.

In the meantime, cut the pork, vote down ridiculous big government bills like the vaccination bill for girls that was recently introduced, and learn to operate lean and mean until the "business friendly" acts have time to mature and draw more businesses to the state. It makes sense to me.

These sort of issues make me wonder how states like Tennessee do so well without onerous state tax burdens on businesses and individuals -- for crying out loud, there is no state income tax in that state but their roads are well-maintained and their cities are robust and growing, their school systems are doing well, and no one ever seems to mention that in the Kentucky legislature.

Hey, I'm sure a lot of us would be willing to foot the tax bill just for a few of our state senators to go to Tennessee and learn from them! Look, I'd never want to live there but I can't help but think they've got the market cornered on how to run a state responsibly... am I wrong there?

Popular posts from this blog

Louisville Tea Party -- July 4, 2009

Help us make it known to Comrade Obama and his goons on Capitol Hill that July 4th is INdependence Day , not COdependence day! Louisville's patriots are throwing a TEA Party on Saturday, July 4th in Jefferson Square (6th and Jefferson) from 11am - 2pm. Hope to see you there!!

Friday Night with Hugh and Friends

The consummate Conservative host, Hugh Hewitt, and yours truly! Shameless of me to post this, I know; however, I'm too jazzed to care. :-p What a wonderful way to spend a Friday night! After an hour or so wandering through some of the exhibits at the Frazier Historical Arms Museum, I then got to spend three hours with Hugh Hewitt and 599 other fans of his show. I absolutely MUST say that not only was Hugh wonderful and the live show very entertaining, but his fans are absolutely the nicest people! I've seen other radio talk show s done live and mingled with fans of those shows. Hugh Hewitt's fans are the nicest, most down to earth, friendly people I've ever met. It's quite a credit to Hugh that he draws such a fan base. If you haven't been to the Frazier Historical Arms Museum here in Louisville, it's a must-see. The museum shows an amazing artistry with the exhibits and places them in the context of the times in a very entertaining and educationa

As the Blog Turns...

Gee. I have found myself fascinated by the soap opera unfolding in the comments section of this blog since last night. One little mention on a controversial Democrat's blog and it's High Noon on ConservaChick! (Yes, I'm laughing while I type this.) For those of you who have no idea what's happening in the ever-expanding comments section , join the club! Here's what I know about Mark Nickolas from bits and pieces I've read on his blog, and from a local news report: Nickolas likes to sneer at Republicans and call them snide little nicknames as he provides his "Unfiltered and Candid Look at Politics, Politicians and the Media in Kentucky;" he raised a ruckus within the Democrat party here in Kentucky by filing a suit against the chairman of the party , Jerry Lundergan; and he will be appearing on the same panel with yours truly on Thursday night. That's about it. You now have the benefit of my not-so-extensive knowledge on this subject. Nickolas poste